Knoke, T.; Stimm, B. & Weber, M. (2008): <b>Tropical farmers need productive alternatives</b>. <i>Nature</i> <b>452</b>, 934.
Resource Description
Title:
Tropical farmers need productive alternatives
Short Name:
Tropical farmers
FOR816dw ID:
112
Publication Date:
2008-04-24
License and Usage Rights:
Resource Owner(s):
Individual:
Thomas Knoke
Contact:
email:
knoke <at> forst.tu-muenchen.de
Center of Life and Food Science Weihenstephan
Institute of Forest Management
Technische Universität München
Hans-Carl-von-Carlowitz-Platz 2
85354 Freising
Germany
Individual:
Bernd Stimm
Contact:
email:
stimm <at> forst.tu-muenchen.de
Dep. of Ecology
Hans-Carl-von-Carlowitz-Platz 2
Technische Universität München
Institute of Silviculture
85354 Freising
Germany
Individual:
Michael Weber
Contact:
email:
m.weber <at> forst.wzw.tum.de
Am Hochanger 13
D-85354 Freising
Dep. Ecology and Ecosystem Management
Technische Universitaet Muenchen
Institute of Silviculture
85354 Freising
Germany
Abstract:
SIR ? Your Editorial ?Markets can save forests? proposes integrating deforestation into the international carbon market (Nature 452, 127?128; 2008), but it is unlikely that money alone can solve the problem. <br/>
The process of tropical deforestation presents a dilemma: enormous economic value more than US$ 2,000 a year per hectare is lost in favour of small private benefits (often less than US$ 100 a year per hectare). In a true market, an increased, scarcity-signalling price should provide an incentive to boost the supply of the scarce commodity. So far, this has not worked in the case of tropical forests. Real financial flows received for the provision of ecosystem services are vanishingly small, if they exist at all ? only a few beneficiaries have been convinced to pay for environmental services. This illustrates the essentially theoretical character (at least, up till now) of economic values generated by ecosystem services.<br/>
Payments for ecosystem services (PES) are supposed to save tropical forests. But even if it were possible to mobilize substantial PES, tropical farmers wouldn?t be prepared to stand by and twiddle their thumbs while receiving these payments to protect the forest. They need a field of activity, so sustainable land-use concepts should address the social environment and needs of people as well. These concepts could be linked and possibly financed by PES.<br/>
If the people who use tropical lands are disregarded, we don?t believe that PES will solve the problem of disappearing tropical forests. What is needed is an economic system that keeps people gainfully employed in an activity that is ultimately productive, not destructive.<br/>
Literature type specific fields:
ARTICLE
Journal:
Nature
Volume:
452
Page Range:
934
Publisher:
NATURE PUBLISHING GROUP, MACMILLAN BUILDING, 4 CRINAN ST, LONDON N1 9XW, ENGLAND
Metadata Provider:
Individual:
Thomas Knoke
Contact:
email:
knoke <at> forst.tu-muenchen.de
Center of Life and Food Science Weihenstephan
Institute of Forest Management
Technische Universität München
Hans-Carl-von-Carlowitz-Platz 2
85354 Freising
Germany
